Skip to main content

Table 3 The individual study-based data analysis to evaluate the effectiveness of these interventions on macular hole closure rate and VMT release rate

From: Pneumatic vitreolysis versus vitrectomy for the treatment of vitreomacular traction syndrome and macular holes: complication analysis and systematic review with meta-analysis of functional outcomes

Study

Macular hole

Study

Vitreomacular traction (VMT)

Treatment

Events

Total

 

Treatment

Events

Total

Benz et al. [37]

Ocriplasmin

6

34

Primavera et al. [53]

PV

4

4

Cacciamani et al. [61]

Ocriplasmin

11

23

Čokl et al. [54]

PV

18

29

Cacciamani et al. [62]

Ocriplasmin

11

16

Gruchociak et al. [63]

PV

7

11

Khanani et al. [64]

Ocriplasmin

283

480

Han et al. [41]

PV

10

26

Iuliano et al. [65]

Ocriplasmin

9

16

Arrigo et al. [66]

Ocriplasmin

40

73

Chatziralli et al. [67]

Ocriplasmin

16

24

Bormann et al. [68]

Ocriplasmin

7

10

Wertheimer et al. [69]

Ocriplasmin

13

40

Muqit et al. [46]

Ocriplasmin

4

25

Dugel et al. [40]

Ocriplasmin

55

145

Schumann et al. [49]

Ocriplasmin

28

57

Pirani et al. [70]

Ocriplasmin

9

15

Sharma et al. [50]

Ocriplasmin

21

34

Feng et al. [42]

Ocriplasmin

12

49

Steel et al. [57]

Ocriplasmin

120

295

Meyer et al. [71]

Ocriplasmin

14

22

Makris et al. [72]

Ocriplasmin

15

35

Mastropasqua et al. [73]

Ocriplasmin

7

14

Tadayoni et al. [74]

PPV

15

15

Muqit et al. [46]

Ocriplasmin

4

6

Zandi et al. [58]

Ocriplasmin

34

51

Nudleman et al. [47]

Ocriplasmin

15

36

Seamone et al. [75]

PV

11

20

Quezada-Ruiz et al. [48]

Ocriplasmin

11

23

Anderson et al. [21]

PV

7

9

Schumann et al. [49]

Ocriplasmin

17

25

Baumann et al. [59]

PV

35

47

Stalmans et al. [11]

Ocriplasmin

7

13

Fouad et al. [23]

PV

24

30

Makris et al. [72]

Ocriplasmin

1

3

Özdemir et al. [20]

PV

11

11

Warrow et al. [76]

Ocriplasmin

15

35

    

Willekens et al. [52]

Ocriplasmin

27

38

    

Itoh et al. [77]

Ocriplasmin

9

19

    

Kannan et al. [78]

PPV

77

77

    

Cereda et al. [79]

Ocriplasmin

12

15

    

Barca et al. [80]

Ocriplasmin

44

74

    

Paul et al. [81]

Ocriplasmin

79

167

    

Pessoa et al. [82]

Ocriplasmin

27

59

    

Wickens et al. [55]

PPV

20

21

    

Bormann et al. [68]

Ocriplasmin

4

10

    

Pessoa et al. [83]

Ocriplasmin

14

23

    

Nambiar et al. [27]

Ocriplasmin

7

17

    

Kim et al. [84]

Ocriplasmin

8

19

    

Scholz et al. [34]

Ocriplasmin

7

14

    

Schumann et al. [85]

Ocriplasmin

45

82

    

Sharma et al. [50]

Ocriplasmin

12

32

    

Steinle et al. [35]

Ocriplasmin

7

14

    

Tadayoni et al. [74]

PPV

4

4

    

Zandi et al. [58]

Ocriplasmin

15

21

    

Novack et al. [86]

Ocriplasmin

31

74

    

Sharma et al. [87]

Ocriplasmin

29

58

    

Figueira et al. [88]

Ocriplasmin

47

83

    

Tschuppert et al. [89]

Ocriplasmin

5

12

    

Reiss et al. [90]

Ocriplasmin

3

10

    

Singh et al. [91]

Ocriplasmin

8

17

    

Manousaridis et al. [92]

Ocriplasmin

12

35

    

Lim et al. [45]

Ocriplasmin

90

200

    

Chaudhary et al. [93]

PPV

220

238

    

Hejsek et al. [60]

PPV

28

30

    

Dihowm et al. [39]

PPV

136

142

    

Čokl et al. [54]

PV

1

4

    

Han et al. [41]

PV

17

26

    

Steel et al. [57]

Ocriplasmin

12

89

    

Baumann et al. [59]

PV

4

14

    

Özdemir et al. [20]

PV

0

2

    

Formula = \(\frac{{\mathrm{Number\, of\, Events}}}{{\mathrm{Total \,Number \,of\, eyes}}}\times 100\)

Total number of patients for MH treatment by ocriplasmin = \(\frac{1070}{2201}\times 100=48\cdot 6\%\)

Total number of patients for MH treatment by ocriplasmin = \(\frac{269}{580}\times 100=46\%\)

Total number of patients for MH treatment by PV = \(\frac{22}{46}\times 100=47\cdot 8\%\)

Total number of patients for MH treatment by PV = \(\frac{127}{187}\times 100=68\%\)

Total number of patients for MH treatment by PPV = \(\frac{485}{ 512}\times 100=95\%\)

Total number of patients for MH treatment by PPV = \(\frac{15}{15}\times 100=100\%\)

  1. MH, macular hole; PV, pneumatic vitreolysis; PPV, pars plana vitrectomy; VMT, vitreomacular traction