- Original article
- Open Access
Investigation of new dyes for chromovitrectomy: preclinical biocompatibility of trisodium, orangell and methyl violet
International Journal of Retina and Vitreousvolume 1, Article number: 1 (2015)
To investigate the retinal toxicity by electroretinography (ERG), clinical examination and histology after intravitreal injection of biological stains in two concentrations: Trisodium (0.50 g/L and 1.00 g/L), Orangell (0.25 g/L and 1.00 g/L) and Methyl Violet (0.50 g/L and 1.00 g/L).
Eighteen New-Zealand albinos rabbits were assigned in six groups (n = 3 in each group). The animals in group 1 received Trisodium in the dose of 0.50 g/L and group 2 received 1.00 g/L; Group 3 received Orangell in the dose of 0.25 g/L and group 4 received 1.00 g/L; Group 5 received Methyl Violet in the dose of 1.00 g/L and group 6 received 0.50 g/L. A volume of 0.05 mL of dye was injected in the right eyes, whereas the left eyes received the same volume of balanced salt solution (BSS) as control. ERG recordings and clinical examination were performed at baseline and seven days after intravitreal injection. The ERG responses at one week after injection were compared with baseline levels. A decrease in the post-injection amplitude of more than 50% was considered remarkable. After the 7-day follow-up, rabbits were euthanized and eye enucleated for light microscopy (LM) histological evaluation.
At clinical examination by indirect ophthalmoscopy seven days after dye injection, all eyes were negative for cataract, hemorrhage, retinal detachment, and intraocular opacities. Amplitude analysis of maximum scotopic b-wave showed no significant reduction in either dye injected or control eyes. Neither dye nor BSS caused significant retinal alteration on LM at doses tested.
Trisodium, Orangell and Methyl Violet can be applied in future studies in order to prove the capacity to stain preretinal tissues and vitreous without toxicity. The three dyes did not induce significant ERG amplitude reduction or LM alterations in this preliminary experimental research. Trisodium, Orangell and Methyl Violet may be potentially useful vital dyes for ocular surgery, and deserve further investigation.
Pars plana vitrectomy enables treatment of important diseases of the retina such as diabetic retinopathy, macular hole and retinal detachment. The removal of internal limiting membrane (ILM) and preretinal membranes, such as those proliferative vitreoretinopathy, may be a technically difficult surgical step, as these are thin and semi-transparent tissues. Chromovitrectomy refers to the use of dyes to stain preretinal membranes and vitreous, facilitating their intraoperative visualization and removal, thus meaning an advance in surgical technique and consequent improvement of surgical outcomes .
Initially, indocyanine green (ICG) dye was shown to stain avidly the internal limiting membrane (ILM) . However, numerous reports have raised concerns over retinal toxicity after intravitreous ICG injection [3-5], and subsequently, different agents arose as newer alternative for vital dyes, such as Trypan Blue (TB), Brilliant Blue (BriB) and Triamcinolone Acetonide (TA) [6-8]. While TB has good staining capacity for epiretinal membranes (ERM), BB stains ILM elements, and TA deposits well in the acellular vitreous [9-11]. BriB showed good biocompatibility for chromovitrectomy and emerged as an alternative to ICG in chromovitrectomy [12,13]. However, the safest and best dye with high affinity for ILM and ERM is yet to be determined.
The development of novel vital dyes is under intense investigation and several dyes have been tested in recent years in search of the ideal dye as the inappropriate use of these substances can lead to toxicity and considerable functional loss.
Controversy about the optimal dye increases. An ideal vital dye for chromovitrectomy must be capable of selectively staining the internal limiting membrane and epiretinal membrane, leaving the retina unstained, and providing adequate colour difference between the ERM/ILM and the retina. Providing adequate color difference between the ILM/ERM stained and normal retina. Other favorable characteristics are rapid elimination from the vitreous cavity, photochemical stability, solubility in BSS, lack of toxicity, and proper light absorption profile .
For this study, a total of three chemical biological stains were selected: Methyl Violet (MV); Trisodium (TR); and Orangell (OR). The aim of this paper was to investigate in vivo the retinal biocompatibility of these three dyes injected intravitreally into rabbits’ eyes with clinical examination, histology with light microscopy (LM) and electroretinography (ERG).
Dye solutions, pH, osmolarity, and light absorbing properties
A total of 5 and 10 mg of TR and MV (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), 2,5 and 10 mg of OR (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), in the powder form, were weighed with an analytical balance (Mettler-Toledo Inc., Columbus) and suspended in 10 mL of solvent, glucose 5%, water or BSS, to obtain a concentration of 0.05 g/L and 0.10 g/L for TR and MV, 0.025 g/L and 0.10 g/L OR. The mixtures were shaken for 5 minutes and sonicated (Unique Ind., Idaiatuba, Brazil) to obtain a complete solution. The pH was measured with a pH meter (Quimis Inc., Diadema, Brazil), whereas osmolarity was determined with an osmometer (Advanced Instruments Inc., Norwood). Vital dyes with pH and osmolarity closest to 7.0 and 290 mOsm were selected for the experiments. Spectral absorption was measured with a spectrometer between 200 and 1,000 nm immediately after preparation (Spectronic Genesys 5, Milton Roy).
Animals and surgical technique for Intravitreal injection of vital dyes in Rabbits’ eyes
A total of 18 male rabbits, 1.8 to 2.5 kg, were used in accordance with the guidelines set forth by the ARVO (Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology) Statement for the Use of Animals in Ophthalmic and Vision Research and with the university guidelines regarding animal experimentation in ophthalmic and vision research. The animals were fed standard laboratory food and allowed free access to water in an air-conditioned room with a 12-hour light–dark cycle.
After the preparation of the drug solutions, 0.1 mL of 0.05 g/L or 0.10 g/L MV, 0.05 g/L or 0.10 g/L TR, 0.025 g/L or 0.10 g/L OR was injected into the vitreous cavity of the right eye (OD), and 0.1 mL of BSS (290 mOsm) into the left eye (OS) was used as control. After the placement of a lid speculum, a drop of topical povidone 5% iodine was instilled followed by BSS washout. The vitreous cavity was entered through the superotemporal sclera 2 mm posterior to the limbus using a 27-gauge needle connected to a 1-mL syringe containing dye or control solution. One drop of antibiotic–steroid solution was then instilled.
Clinical evaluation with fundoscopy and biomicroscopy
Indirect ophthalmoscopy and slit-lamp biomicroscopy were performed before the injection, immediately after and 7 days after. Indirect ophthalmoscopy (Keeler Instruments, Broomall) and slit-lamp biomicroscopy were performed for detection of corneal clarity, appearance of the lens and retina, conjunctival reaction, and vitreous hazing.
In vivo functional retinal toxicity by ERG
Electroretinography recordings were taken before the intravitreal injection (baseline) and 7 days after intravitreal injection. The rabbits were anesthetized with intramuscular injection of a solution containing 1 mL of ketamine (50 mg/mL) and 0.4 mL of xylazine (10 mg/mL). The pupils were dilated (tropicamide 1%) and the cornea was anesthetized with 1% proparacaine drops. The rabbits were placed on a heating pad during the experiment, unipolar contact lenses with ERG jet electrodes (Universe SA, La Chaux-de-Fonds, Switzerland) were put on both corneas with 2% methylcellulose (Ophthalmos, São Paulo, Brazil). A reference electrode filled with electrolytic gel was placed at the temporal cantus of the eyelid, whereas the ground electrode also filled with gel, was placed on the ear lobe. They were then presented in a Ganzfeld stimulator of the Veris system (Electro-Diagnostic Imaging Inc., San Mateo). After 30 minutes of dark adaptation, the procedure was performed and peak-to-peak amplitude analysis in scotopic maximal responses were analyzed. The responses one week after injection were compared with baseline levels. A decrease in the post-injection response of >50% in scotopic maximal b-wave was considered significant.
In vivo morphologic retinal toxicity and cell counting with light microscopy
After the 7-day follow-up, rabbits were euthanized with intravenous injection of 120 mg/kg sodium pentobarbital and the eyes were enucleated for light microscopy (LM) histological evaluation. All eyes were sectioned in half and fixed at 4°C in a mixture of 2.5% glutaraldehyde and 4% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 moles/L phosphate buffer at pH 7.4. The specimens were stained en bloc with lead citrate, washed three times in 0.1moles/L phosphate buffer, and dehydrated with ethyl alcohol. Then, the specimens were embedded and stained with 1% toluidine blue and examined with an Optiphot-2TM (Nikon, Tokyo, Japan) for LM. Samples were collected from two different areas in all the dye-injected eyes in three serial sections: 500 μm inferior to the optic nerve and 4 mm from the optic nerve at the temporal-inferior quadrant. A horizontal diameter of the retinal surface of 1,100 μm was used for detailed analysis of retinal toxicity.
For histological evaluation of the degree of cellular injury, cellular abnormalities such as vacuolization, edema, or necrosis were described as “no” changes, “focal” abnormalities with less than 12 cells/ structures damaged, or “diffuse” changes with more than 12 cells/structures damaged [13,15]. Eyes were analyzed by two masked examiners in regard to dye, concentration and exposure to avoid bias. The inner and outer nuclear layers were counted for number of cells with the software program NIH ImageJ (NIH, Bethesda) within the 1,100 μm horizontal surface. The eyes of the dye group were compared with the BSS-control group; statistical analysis was performed using analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by the Newman–Keuls test with a specific software program (GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego).
Dye solutions, osmolarity measurements, and light absorbing properties
Mixed and sonicated dye preparations were used as complete solutions for injections. MV, TR and OR dyes were chosen in the BSS solvent. The osmolarity of selected dyes for experiments ranged from 267 mOsm to 315 mOsm, whereas pH values were within 6.85 and 7.23. Most vital dyes showed substantial absorption between 450 and 650 nm, whereas no agent demonstrated spectral absorption above 700 nm (Table 1).
Clinical evaluation with fundoscopy and biomicroscopy
After intravitreal injection, MV, TR and OR appeared as a floating purple, green or orange mass in the vitreous. At clinical examination by indirect ophthalmoscopy and slit-lamp biomicroscopy, seven days after dye injection, all eyes were negative for cataract, hemorrhage, retinal detachment, intraocular opacities, corneal desepitelization, infiltration and conjunctival reaction. No other adverse effects were observed in our study.
Morphologic retinal toxicity with light microscopy
No major anatomic signs of toxicity were found in the histology of both experimental and control eyes. The histopathological appearance of the retina, choroid and sclera was within “focal” abnormalities without any signs of severe retinal necrosis or cystic degeneration. Nerve fiber layer, retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and choriocapillaris showed focal abnormalities after 1 week of the injection in every group analyzed. Concerning retinal damage, seven days after intravitreal dye injection, either the control or the study group examination in both concentrations showed only sparse regions in the retina of vacuolization and edema. Groups receiving Trisodium presented focal areas of vacuolization in the nerve fiber layer, ganglion cells layer and inner nuclear layer, with no major retinal damage (Figure 1). Groups receiving Orangell showed focal areas of vacuolization in the nerve fiber layer, ganglion cells layer, inner nuclear layer and outer nuclear layer, with no major retinal damage (Figure 2). Concerning groups receiving Methyl Violet, focal areas of vacuolization occurred in the nerve fiber layer, ganglion cells layer, inner nuclear layer and outer nuclear layer, with mild distortion of the retinal structure (Figure 3). One rabbit in Group 5 receiving Methyl Violet in the dose of 1.00 g/L presented focal areas of thinning of inner retina in both treated and control eyes and one rabbit in Group 6 receiving Methyl Violet in the dose of 0.50 g/L presented multinucleated cells in the ganglion cells layer.
Functional retinal evaluation with ERG
At the doses tested, MV, TR and OR caused no statistical alterations in ERG during the follow-up period. Amplitude analysis of maximal scotopic b-wave showed no significant reduction in either dye injected or control eyes (p > 0.05). Scotopic b-wave amplitude in both eyes showed no statistical decrease (Table 2).
Vital dyes may be used to facilitate intraoperative surgical procedures such as ILM or ERM-peeling [16-18]. In this rabbit-model study, the retinal biocompatibility of MV, TR and OR were determined to evaluate these dyes as alternatives in chromovitrectomy.
In the histological analysis of eyes injected with Trisodium, Orangell and Methyl Violet some aspects could be observed, such as slight distortion of major retina, none vitreous cells or alterations, focal areas of vacuolization in the nerve fiber layer and outer nuclear layer/photoreceptors with no other findings, except for one rabbit in Group 5 receiving Methyl Violet in the dose of 1.00 g/L that presented focal areas of thinning of inner retina in both treated and control eyes and one rabbit in Group 6 receiving Methyl Violet in the dose of 0.50 g/L that presented multinucleated cells in the ganglion cells layer. Overall, we observed herein good retinal biocompatibility of MV, TR and OR in our experiments in rabbits’ eyes.
The electroretinogram (ERG) was used for detecting and to quantify possible retinal toxicity after intravitreal dye injection in our experiments in rabbits’ eyes. Considering remarkable a decrease in the postinjection response of >50%, intravitreal MV, TR and OR injections caused no major changes in ERG-examination during the follow-up period. Nevertheless, normal ERG results do not rule out functional and possible structural changes at the level of ganglion cells or the nerve fiber layer. Maximal scotopic b-wave record was used as the most important parameter of toxicity according to other studies in literature supporting this to be the best evidence of drug toxicity in animal models [13,15].
The investigation of dyes and drugs applied on the retina may be accomplished in cell culture or animal experiments. Cell culture models with retinal pigment epithelial or neuroretinal cells, e.g., R28 cells, may allow systematic evaluation of drug toxicity in a controlled fashion. In a cell culture system, a chemical agent may be found to be safe at certain concentrations, while in-vivo evaluation may show specific signs of damage, such as vacuolization and loss of cells. These observations may result from the complexity of the intraocular milieu, making it difficult to replicate in a cell or tissue culture system.
Research in animal models is usually considered better evidence of pharmacological activity compared to cell culture alone, since it simulates better the human ocular and retinal environment. Results in human chromovitrectomy may not correspond to results obtained in animal models, as interspecies variations occur. In our research, we did not find considerable anatomical or functional damage to the retinal layers.
The limitation of our investigation is that only two concentrations were tested, in contrast to the large number of concentrations that can be examined in cell culture research. This study did not evaluate the affinity to the ILM; therefore it should be performed eventually. Also, this study does not rule out the possibility that longer-term follow-up in the New-Zealand albino rabbits or in human subjects might show untoward side effects. The comparison of potential and novel dye in an animal model is the main advantage of our study.
In conclusion, Trisodium, Orangell and Methyl Violet did not induce significant ERG amplitude reduction or LM alterations in this preliminary experimental research. This suggests that the capacity of these three dyes to stain vitreous and preretinal tissues can be studied without major toxicity concerns and indicating that these dyes could potentially be used in future chromovitrectomy studies in order validate our findings.
Balanced salt solution
Photopic 30 Hz flicker b- wave
Internal limiting membrane
Maximum scotopic a- wave
Minimal scotopic b-wave
Retinal pigment epithelium
Photopic single flash cone b-wave
Rodrigues EB, Meyer CH, Kroll P. Chromovitrectomy: a new field in vitreoretinal surgery. Graefe’s archive for clinical and experimental ophthalmology = Albrecht von Graefes Archiv fur klinische und experimentelle Ophthalmologie. 2005;243(4):291–3.
Burk SE, Da Mata AP, Snyder ME, Rosa Jr RH, Foster RE. Indocyanine green-assisted peeling of the retinal internal limiting membrane. Ophthalmology. 2000;107(11):2010–4.
Gandorfer A, Haritoglou C, Gandorfer A, Kampik A. Retinal damage from indocyanine green in experimental macular surgery. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2003;44(1):316–23.
Maia M, Margalit E, Lakhanpal R, Tso MO, Grebe R, Torres G, et al. Effects of intravitreal indocyanine green injection in rabbits. Retina. 2004;24(1):69–79.
Rodrigues EB, Meyer CH, Farah ME, Kroll P. Intravitreal staining of the internal limiting membrane using indocyanine green in the treatment of macular holes. Ophthalmologica. 2005;219(5):251–62.
Teba FA, Mohr A, Eckardt C, Wong D, Kusaka S, Joondeph BC, et al. Trypan blue staining in vitreoretinal surgery. Ophthalmology. 2003;110(12):2409–12.
Mennel S, Meyer CH, Tietjen A, Rodrigues EB, Schmidt JC. Patent blue: a novel vital dye in vitreoretinal surgery. Ophthalmologica. 2006;220(3):190–3.
Albini TA, Abd-El-Barr MM, Carvounis PE, Iyer MN, Lakhanpal RR, Pennesi ME, et al. Long-term retinal toxicity of intravitreal commercially available preserved triamcinolone acetonide (Kenalog) in rabbit eyes. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2007;48(1):390–5.
Peyman GA, Cheema R, Conway MD, Fang T. Triamcinolone acetonide as an aid to visualization of the vitreous and the posterior hyaloid during pars plana vitrectomy. Retina. 2000;20(5):554–5.
Feron EJ, Veckeneer M, Parys-Van Ginderdeuren R, Van Lommel A, Melles GR, Stalmans P. Trypan blue staining of epiretinal membranes in proliferative vitreoretinopathy. Arch Ophthalmol. 2002;120(2):141–4.
Enaida H, Ishibashi T. Brilliant blue in vitreoretinal surgery. Dev Ophthalmol. 2008;42:115–25.
Januschowski K, Mueller S, Spitzer MS, Schramm C, Doycheva D, Bartz-Schmidt KU, et al. Evaluating retinal toxicity of a new heavy intraocular dye, using a model of perfused and isolated retinal cultures of bovine and human origin. Graefe’s archive for clinical and experimental ophthalmology = Albrecht von Graefes Archiv fur klinische und experimentelle Ophthalmologie. 2012;250(7):1013–22.
Rodrigues EB, Penha FM, Farah ME, de Paula Fiod Costa E, Maia M, Dib E. Preclinical investigation of the retinal biocompatibility of six novel vital dyes for chromovitrectomy. Retina. 2009;29(4):497–510.
Narayanan R, Kenney MC, Kamjoo S, Trinh TH, Seigel GM, Resende GP, et al. Trypan blue: effect on retinal pigment epithelial and neurosensory retinal cells. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2005;46(1):304–9.
Cardoso EB, Moraes-Filho M, Rodrigues EB, Maia M, Penha FM, Novais EA, et al. Investigation of the retinal biocompatibility of acid violet for chromovitrectomy. Graefe’s archive for clinical and experimental ophthalmology = Albrecht von Graefes Archiv fur klinische und experimentelle Ophthalmologie. 2013;251(4):1115–21.
Dib E, Rodrigues EB, Maia M, Meyer CH, Penha FM, Furlani Bde A, et al. [Vital dyes in chromovitrectomy]. Arquivos brasileiros de oftalmologia. 2009;72(6):845–50.
Meyer CH. Vital dyes in vitreoretinal surgery chromovitrectomy. Preface. Dev Ophthalmol. 2008;42:11–2.
Rodrigues EB, Maia M, Meyer CH, Penha FM, Dib E, Farah ME. Vital dyes for chromovitrectomy. Curr Opin Ophthalmol. 2007;18(3):179–87.
From the German Academic Exchange Service (DAAD); from the Pan-American Association of Ophthalmology- Pan-American Ophthalmological Foundation (PAAO/PAOF); from the Vision Institute – UNIFESP; and to the FAPESP - Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
EB, RASL, MM, EAN participated in the design, performed the experiments, participated to draft the manuscript. CHM, MEF and EBR conceived the study, participated in the design, participated to draft the manuscript. FH participated in the design of the study and performed the statistical analysis. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.